Feasibility Analysis: Utilizing Retirement Plan Rollovers for SDIRA-Funded SFR Investments by Federal and Georgia State Employees

I. Executive Summary

Overview: This report analyzes the feasibility for federal employees (covered by FERS, CSRS, TSP) and State of Georgia employees (covered by ERSGA, TRSGA, JRS, GSPERS, Peach State Reserves) to use rollovers from their retirement plans to fund a Self-Directed Individual Retirement Arrangement (SDIRA) for the purpose of investing in single-family residential (SFR) real estate strategies. The core finding is that while SDIRAs permit such investments, the ability for active employees to fund them by rolling over assets from their primary defined benefit (DB) pension plans (FERS, CSRS, ERSGA, TRSGA, JRS, GSPERS) is severely restricted, often impossible without separating from service and forfeiting the guaranteed lifetime annuity in favor of a refund of employee contributions.

Key Hurdles: A fundamental distinction exists between DB pension annuities, which represent a future income stream and are generally not rollable assets, and defined contribution (DC) plan balances (like the TSP, Peach State Reserves 401k/457b, and other supplemental 401k/403b/457b plans), which are account-based and potentially rollable. However, even for DC plans, rollover eligibility is typically contingent upon separation from service or, for some plans, reaching age 59.5 while still employed. Active employees below age 59.5 face significant barriers to accessing their primary retirement funds for this strategy.

SFR Strategy Considerations: Utilizing an SDIRA for SFR investments—whether through direct ownership, private debt funds, or first trust deeds—introduces substantial complexities. These include navigating intricate IRS compliance rules (prohibited transactions, disqualified persons), managing illiquid assets, conducting rigorous due diligence on investments and counterparties, and potentially facing Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT) or Unrelated Debt-Financed Income (UDFI) taxes within the retirement account. These factors may undermine the objective of seeking “safety” and stability compared to traditional, liquid, diversified investment portfolios.

Recommendation: Pursuing this strategy demands extreme caution. The limitations on accessing primary pension funds, particularly for active employees, are significant. The operational complexities and inherent risks of SDIRA real estate investing require specialized knowledge and meticulous compliance. Thorough due diligence and consultation with qualified, independent financial, tax, and legal professionals experienced in both public sector plans and SDIRAs are strongly advised before initiating any rollovers or investments. For many employees, especially those actively employed and under age 59.5, alternative diversification strategies within existing plan options or using non-retirement assets may prove more practical and less fraught with risk.

II. The Self-Directed IRA Landscape for Real Estate

A. Defining the Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA)

An SDIRA is a specific type of Individual Retirement Arrangement (IRA) that permits the account holder to invest in a broader range of assets than typically allowed in standard IRAs offered by mainstream brokerage firms and banks.¹ While standard IRAs usually restrict investments to publicly traded stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and CDs, SDIRAs are designed to accommodate alternative investments such as real estate, precious metals, private equity, private loans, and more.¹

The key operational difference lies with the custodian. U.S. tax law requires all IRAs to be held by a trustee or custodian.¹ Most custodians limit investment options because they lack the infrastructure or expertise to administer complex alternative assets.² SDIRAs, however, are administered by specialized custodians willing to hold and administer these less common, often illiquid, and harder-to-value assets.¹ These custodians facilitate the “self-directed” nature, allowing the account owner significant control over investment choices, provided they do not violate IRS regulations.¹

Like standard IRAs, SDIRAs can be established as either Traditional or Roth accounts. Traditional SDIRAs involve pre-tax contributions (potentially tax-deductible) with taxes due upon distribution in retirement. Roth SDIRAs utilize after-tax contributions, allowing for potentially tax-free growth and tax-free qualified distributions in retirement.¹ The choice between Traditional and Roth depends on the individual’s tax situation and retirement strategy.²

Crucially, the term “self-directed” signifies that the account owner bears complete responsibility for all investment decisions, due diligence, and compliance.⁵ The SDIRA custodian’s role is primarily administrative; they do not provide investment advice, vet the quality or legitimacy of investments, or ensure the investments are suitable for the account holder.⁴ This places a significant burden on the investor to understand the assets they are acquiring and the intricate rules governing SDIRAs.⁵

B. Permissible SFR Investments within an SDIRA

The IRS rules define what investments are prohibited in an IRA, rather than listing what is allowed.⁵ Generally, if an investment is not explicitly prohibited (like life insurance, collectibles, or S-Corp stock ²), it can potentially be held in an SDIRA, provided the custodian is willing to administer it.¹ Real estate is one of the most popular asset classes held within SDIRAs.² Several SFR-related strategies are commonly employed:

• Direct Ownership: The SDIRA can directly purchase and hold title to various types of real estate, including single-family homes, duplexes, condominiums, townhomes, apartment buildings, commercial properties, and even raw land.¹ This allows the IRA to potentially benefit from rental income and property appreciation on a tax-advantaged basis.⁷ Common strategies include long-term rentals, short-term rentals (e.g., Airbnb), property rehabilitation (“flips”), and holding land for development.³ A critical rule is that all income generated (e.g., rent) must be deposited directly into the SDIRA, and all expenses (property taxes, insurance, repairs, management fees) must be paid directly from the SDIRA funds.⁵
• Private Lending/Debt: Instead of owning property directly, the SDIRA can act as a lender, providing capital to other individuals or entities, often secured by real estate.³ This can take the form of promissory notes, mortgage notes, or deeds of trust.³ The SDIRA earns interest income from these loans, which flows back into the retirement account tax-deferred or tax-free (depending on IRA type).¹⁰ This strategy avoids the responsibilities of direct property ownership and management.³ The terms of the loan (amount, interest rate, repayment schedule, collateral) are typically negotiated between the SDIRA (directed by the owner) and the borrower.³
• Private Debt Funds: An SDIRA can invest as a limited partner or member in a private fund (often structured as an LLC or LP) that specializes in originating or acquiring real estate debt, including loans secured by SFRs.¹¹ This provides diversification across multiple loans and relies on the expertise of the fund manager.¹² The SDIRA receives its pro-rata share of the fund’s income. This is generally a passive investment for the SDIRA owner but requires significant due diligence on the fund manager’s track record, strategy, and fees.¹²
• First Trust Deeds: This is a specific type of private lending where the SDIRA holds the primary (first position) lien on the property securing the loan.³ This position means the SDIRA lender has the first claim on the property if the borrower defaults and foreclosure occurs.¹³ Trust deed investing often involves non-judicial foreclosure processes in many states, which can be faster and less costly than judicial foreclosures associated with traditional mortgages.¹³ The SDIRA earns interest income as specified in the promissory note associated with the trust deed.¹³
• IRA LLC (“Checkbook Control”): An SDIRA can be structured to own 100% of a Limited Liability Company (LLC).³ The IRA owner typically acts as the manager of the LLC and can open a bank account in the LLC’s name, funded by the SDIRA.⁷ This structure allows the manager (IRA owner) to make investment decisions and execute transactions directly from the LLC’s bank account, often via checkbook or debit card, without needing custodian approval for each transaction.³ This can be advantageous for time-sensitive investments like real estate auctions or foreclosures.³ However, the IRA LLC is still subject to all SDIRA rules, including prohibited transactions and disqualified person restrictions.⁷
• Funding Methods: SDIRA real estate investments can be funded in several ways:

• All Cash: Using existing funds within the SDIRA to purchase the asset outright.³
• Partnering: Combining SDIRA funds with personal (non-IRA) funds, funds from another person’s IRA, or funds from unrelated third-party investors.³ Ownership percentages, income, and expenses must be allocated strictly based on the proportion of funds contributed by each party.⁹ Importantly, while partnering for the initial purchase might involve personal funds, ongoing transactions cannot involve disqualified persons.⁹
• Non-Recourse Loan: Obtaining financing where the lender’s only recourse in case of default is the property itself; the lender cannot pursue the SDIRA’s other assets or the IRA owner personally.⁷ These loans typically require higher down payments (e.g., 30-40%) than conventional mortgages.⁸ Using such debt triggers potential UDFI tax implications (discussed below).¹⁶

C. Critical Compliance Rules and Risks

Investing in real estate through an SDIRA carries unique compliance obligations and risks beyond those of traditional investments. Failure to adhere strictly to IRS rules can have severe consequences, potentially jeopardizing the tax-advantaged status of the entire IRA.¹

• Prohibited Transactions: The cornerstone of SDIRA compliance is avoiding prohibited transactions, defined by the IRS as any improper use of the IRA by the account owner, their beneficiary, or any “disqualified person”.¹ These transactions typically involve self-dealing or conflicts of interest where a disqualified person benefits improperly from the IRA’s assets.¹ Examples include the IRA buying property from or selling property to a disqualified person, lending IRA money to or borrowing from a disqualified person, or a disqualified person using IRA property.¹ Engaging in a prohibited transaction can result in the IRS treating the entire IRA as distributed as of the first day of the year the transaction occurred, leading to immediate taxation of the full account value, plus potential early withdrawal penalties (10% if under age 59.5).¹ Additional excise taxes may apply to disqualified persons who participate.²⁰
• Disqualified Persons: Understanding who constitutes a disqualified person is critical. This includes ⁵:

• The IRA owner
• The owner’s spouse
• The owner’s ancestors (parents, grandparents)
• The owner’s lineal descendants (children, grandchildren) and their spouses
• Fiduciaries providing investment advice or services to the IRA (including the custodian in some contexts)
• Entities (corporations, partnerships, trusts) in which disqualified persons own 50% or more. The SDIRA cannot engage in virtually any transaction with these individuals or entities. For direct real estate ownership, this means the IRA cannot buy a property from the owner or a relative, sell or lease property to them, or pay them for services related to the property (like repairs or management).⁵

• Self-Dealing / Personal Benefit: A core principle is that IRA assets must be held exclusively for the benefit of the retirement account, not for the personal use or benefit of the owner or other disqualified persons.¹ For real estate, this means the IRA owner or their family cannot live in, vacation in, or otherwise personally use property owned by the SDIRA, even if paying rent.⁶ All income (like rent) must go directly into the IRA, and all expenses must be paid from the IRA.⁵ Personally performing maintenance or repairs on an IRA-owned property, even seemingly minor tasks like mowing the lawn, is considered providing a service and constitutes prohibited self-dealing.⁷ Third parties must be hired and paid with IRA funds for such work.⁸
• Prohibited Investments: The IRS specifically prohibits IRAs from investing in life insurance contracts and collectibles (such as artwork, rugs, antiques, gems, stamps, most coins, and alcoholic beverages).² IRAs also cannot hold stock in an S-Corporation.²
• Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT) / Unrelated Debt-Financed Income (UDFI): Even though IRAs are tax-advantaged, certain types of income generated within them can be subject to tax.

• UBTI (Unrelated Business Taxable Income): This applies if the IRA engages in an active trade or business unrelated to its passive investment purpose.¹⁶ For real estate, income from extensive “fix-and-flip” activities that resemble a dealership business, rather than passive renting or holding for appreciation, could potentially trigger UBTI.¹⁷ Income from an operating business held within the IRA (e.g., through an LLC taxed as a partnership) is also generally UBTI.¹⁸
• UDFI (Unrelated Debt-Financed Income): This is a specific type of UBTI that arises when an IRA uses debt (a non-recourse loan) to acquire or improve an investment property.¹⁶ The portion of the net income (e.g., rental income minus expenses, or capital gains upon sale) attributable to the debt financing is subject to UBIT.¹⁶ The taxable percentage is based on the ratio of the average outstanding debt during the year to the property’s average adjusted basis.¹⁷ For example, if a property is 50% debt-financed, roughly 50% of the net income may be subject to UBIT.¹⁶ Passive income like rent from an unleveraged property, interest, dividends, and capital gains from unleveraged assets are generally exempt from UBIT.¹⁷
• Taxation: If UBIT is owed, the IRA itself must file IRS Form 990-T and pay the tax from its own assets.¹⁷ UBIT is calculated using trust tax rates, which can be quite high, reaching the maximum rate quickly at relatively low income levels.¹⁷ While deductions like depreciation may offset UDFI during the holding period, significant tax liability can arise upon the sale of a leveraged property.¹⁷ There is a $1,000 specific deduction against UBIT.¹⁷
• General Risks: Beyond compliance, SDIRA real estate investing involves inherent market and operational risks:

• Illiquidity: Real estate and private debt are not easily converted to cash, unlike publicly traded securities.⁴ Selling can take time, and may require significant price reductions, especially in down markets.⁸ This lack of liquidity can be problematic if funds are needed unexpectedly or for Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs).⁴
• Potential for Fraud: The alternative investment space is less regulated and transparent than public markets, making it a target for fraudulent schemes.⁴ Investors must be vigilant in vetting deals, sponsors, and counterparties.⁴
• Higher Fees: SDIRA custodians typically charge higher fees (setup, annual, per-asset, transaction) than standard IRA providers.⁴ Real estate itself involves transaction costs and ongoing expenses.⁸
• Complexity and Expertise: Successfully navigating SDIRA rules and evaluating alternative investments requires significant knowledge and effort, or the cost of hiring professional advisors.¹
• Market Fluctuations: Real estate values are subject to market cycles, interest rate changes, and local economic conditions.⁸ Poor location, problem tenants, or unexpected repairs can negatively impact returns.⁹
• Concentration Risk: Investing a large portion of retirement funds into a single property or a small number of notes creates concentration risk, contrary to diversification principles.⁴

The extensive and complex rules governing SDIRAs, particularly the prohibited transaction and self-dealing restrictions, combined with the inherent risks of alternative assets like real estate (illiquidity, valuation challenges, due diligence burden), present a significant counterpoint to the notion that this strategy offers simple “safety” compared to the regulated, liquid, albeit volatile, stock market. The operational and compliance risks are substantial and distinct from market volatility. Failure to navigate these rules correctly carries the severe penalty of potential IRA disqualification.¹

Furthermore, a common misconception may arise regarding the role of the SDIRA custodian. While required for holding the assets ¹, these specialized custodians explicitly do not provide investment advice, perform due diligence, or validate the legitimacy or suitability of the investments held within the account.⁴ Their function is administrative. This places the entire responsibility for vetting investments, ensuring compliance, and understanding risks squarely on the investor.⁵ The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has even warned that fraudsters may leverage this custodian role, falsely implying that custodian acceptance equates to investment legitimacy.⁴ Investors cannot rely on the custodian for protection and must independently verify every aspect of a potential SDIRA investment.

The potential application of UBIT, particularly UDFI when using non-recourse loans ¹⁶, also adds a layer of complexity and potential cost. While leverage can amplify returns, the requirement for the IRA to pay taxes on debt-financed income at potentially high trust rates ¹⁷ diminishes the net benefit compared to an all-cash purchase within the IRA or a leveraged purchase outside the IRA where mortgage interest and depreciation can directly offset the owner’s personal taxable income. This tax drag must be factored into any analysis of leveraged SDIRA real estate investments.

III. Federal Retirement Plan Rollover Analysis

Analyzing the ability of federal employees to roll funds into an SDIRA requires examining the specific rules of the Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), the Federal Employees Retirement System (FERS), and the Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS).

A. Thrift Savings Plan (TSP)

The TSP is a defined contribution (DC) plan, similar to a 401(k), available to federal employees under both FERS and CSRS. Rollover rules depend significantly on employment status and age.

• Rollover Eligibility (Separated/Retired Employees): Upon separation from federal service, participants are generally permitted to roll over their vested TSP account balance to a Traditional IRA (including SDIRA), a Roth IRA (if rolling Roth TSP funds), or another eligible employer-sponsored retirement plan (like a 401(k) or 403(b)).²² This allows consolidation of retirement assets.²³ Both direct rollovers (custodian-to-custodian) and indirect rollovers (participant receives funds and redeposits within 60 days) are possible.²² However, direct rollovers are strongly recommended because if the distribution is paid directly to the participant, the TSP is required to withhold 20% for federal income taxes on the taxable portion.²² To roll over the full amount indirectly, the participant must use other funds to make up the 20% withheld.²² Roth TSP funds must be rolled directly to a Roth IRA or Roth employer plan to maintain their tax-free status; Traditional TSP funds can be rolled to a Traditional IRA or Traditional employer plan.²⁴ A rollover from Traditional TSP to a Roth IRA is possible but constitutes a taxable conversion.²³ Notably, the TSP does not accept incoming rollovers from Roth IRAs.²⁴
• In-Service Withdrawals/Rollovers (Active Employees): Accessing TSP funds for rollover while actively employed is generally restricted, with one key exception:

• Age 59.5 Withdrawals: TSP participants who are still actively employed and are age 59.5 or older are permitted to take up to four “age-based” in-service withdrawals per calendar year from their vested account balance.²⁶ The minimum withdrawal amount is $1,000 (or the entire vested balance if less).²⁷ Crucially, the taxable portion of an age-59.5 withdrawal is subject to the mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding unless the participant elects to have the funds directly rolled over to an IRA (including an SDIRA) or another eligible employer plan.²⁷ This provision offers the primary pathway for an active federal employee to move TSP funds into an SDIRA without separating from service, but only once they reach age 59.5.
• Financial Hardship Withdrawals: These are available only under specific, documented circumstances of financial hardship, such as recurring negative cash flow, certain unpaid medical expenses, personal casualty losses, or legal fees for separation/divorce.²⁶ The minimum withdrawal is $1,000, and participants can only withdraw their own contributions and associated earnings.²⁷ Hardship withdrawals permanently reduce the TSP account balance, are subject to federal and potentially state income taxes, and may incur a 10% early withdrawal penalty if the participant is under age 59.5.²⁶ Importantly, hardship distributions from employer plans are generally not eligible for rollover into an IRA or another plan.²⁵ Therefore, hardship withdrawals are not a viable method for funding an SDIRA.
• TSP Loans: While the TSP allows participants to borrow from their accounts under certain conditions ²³, loan proceeds are not eligible for rollover. Furthermore, IRAs themselves are prohibited from making loans to the account owner.²³ Thus, TSP loans cannot be used to fund an SDIRA.
• Considerations: A significant factor when considering rolling funds out of the TSP is its extremely low administrative and investment expenses.²³ SDIRA custodians and the underlying alternative investments often come with substantially higher fees (setup, annual, asset-based, transaction fees).⁴ Rolling funds out also means losing access to unique TSP investment options, particularly the G Fund (Government Securities Investment Fund), which offers principal protection and a government-guaranteed rate of return.²³

B. Federal Employees Retirement System (FERS) & Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS) Pensions

FERS and CSRS are defined benefit (DB) pension plans, providing a lifetime annuity upon retirement based on factors like years of service and high-three average salary. Their structure fundamentally differs from DC plans like the TSP, significantly impacting rollover possibilities.

• Fundamental Limitation (Annuity vs. Contributions): The core benefit of FERS and CSRS is the promise of a future stream of monthly payments (an annuity) for the retiree’s lifetime. This annuity stream itself is not an account balance and cannot be rolled over into an IRA or SDIRA.²⁵
• Refund of Contributions (Upon Separation): Federal employees covered by FERS or CSRS who leave government service before becoming eligible for an immediate retirement annuity generally have the option to request a refund of their personal retirement contributions made to the system.³⁰ This refund typically includes the employee’s contributions plus applicable interest (interest rules vary slightly between FERS and CSRS and depend on service length).³⁰ A critical consequence of taking this refund is the complete forfeiture of any future FERS or CSRS annuity entitlement based on that period of service.³² Unless the employee later returns to federal service and potentially “redeposits” the refunded amount (rules for redeposit vary and have changed over time), the pension benefit is lost.³⁰
• Rollover of Refund: The lump-sum payment received as a refund of contributions is generally considered an eligible rollover distribution.³⁰ This means the funds can be rolled over into a Traditional IRA (including SDIRA), potentially a Roth IRA (for the after-tax portion), or another eligible employer plan.³⁰ Only the taxable portion of the refund (primarily the accrued interest, as employee contributions were typically made on an after-tax basis under CSRS and FERS) is subject to the mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding if the refund is paid directly to the employee.²⁵ The after-tax contribution portion is not taxed upon refund but can still be rolled over, ideally to a Roth IRA or tracked separately in a Traditional IRA.²⁵ A direct rollover from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) to the IRA custodian avoids the 20% withholding.³⁰
• CSRS Voluntary Contribution Program (VCP): CSRS employees (but not FERS employees) have access to a unique feature called the Voluntary Contribution Program (VCP).³⁸ This allows them to make additional after-tax contributions to a separate account, up to a lifetime limit of 10% of their total career basic pay.³⁸ These VCP funds earn interest and can be withdrawn as a lump sum, potentially even before separation from service (subject to withdrawal rules).⁴⁰ This VCP lump sum (contributions plus interest) can be rolled over to an IRA.³⁸ The after-tax contribution portion can be rolled tax-free (potentially to a Roth IRA), while the accumulated interest is pre-tax and would be taxable upon rollover to a Roth IRA or tax-deferred if rolled to a Traditional IRA.³⁸ The VCP provides a distinct pathway for CSRS employees to move potentially substantial sums into an IRA/SDIRA, bypassing the restrictions on rolling over the main pension benefit. It’s often highlighted as a strategy for making large Roth IRA contributions, especially for those exceeding direct Roth contribution income limits.³⁸
• In-Service Access: Apart from the CSRS VCP, there is generally no mechanism for active federal employees to access or roll over funds from their FERS or CSRS pension accounts. The benefit is tied to future service and retirement eligibility.

The structure of FERS and CSRS as defined benefit plans presents a major obstacle for active employees seeking to use these primary retirement assets to fund an SDIRA. Unlike the TSP’s account balance, the pension represents a future income promise, not a current lump sum available for rollover. The only way to access these funds before retirement eligibility is typically to separate from service and take a contribution refund, thereby sacrificing the guaranteed lifetime pension – a decision with profound long-term financial consequences.³² This fundamental difference between DB and DC plans is critical to understanding the feasibility constraints.

However, the TSP’s age 59.5 in-service withdrawal rule ²⁷ does create a specific opportunity. Active federal employees, whether FERS or CSRS, who are 59.5 or older can potentially access their TSP funds (a DC plan) via a direct rollover to an SDIRA without needing to separate from service. While this doesn’t unlock the pension funds, it provides a viable, albeit limited, window for older active employees to utilize at least part of their federal retirement savings for alternative investments through an SDIRA.

Additionally, the CSRS VCP stands out as a specific exception for CSRS employees.³⁸ It allows them to accumulate additional after-tax savings that are eligible for rollover, potentially pre-separation. This offers a unique avenue for SDIRA funding (or Roth conversion) not available to FERS employees, highlighting an important distinction even within the federal workforce’s retirement options.

IV. Georgia State Retirement Plan Rollover Analysis

Similar to the federal system, Georgia state employees are covered by a mix of defined benefit (DB) pension plans and defined contribution (DC) supplemental plans. Key systems include the Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia (ERSGA), the Teachers Retirement System of Georgia (TRSGA), the Judicial Retirement System (JRS), potentially the Georgia State Pension Fund (GSPERS), and the supplemental Peach State Reserves (PSR) 401(k) and 457(b) plans.

A. Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia (ERSGA) & Teachers Retirement System of Georgia (TRSGA) Pensions

These are the primary retirement systems for many state employees and public school/university system employees, respectively.

• Plan Type: Both ERSGA and TRSGA primarily function as defined benefit (DB) pension plans.⁴¹ They provide retirees with a lifetime monthly income calculated using formulas based on years of creditable service and final average salary (typically highest 24 consecutive months).⁴¹ TRSGA explicitly identifies itself as a qualified 401(a) defined benefit plan.⁴³ ERSGA also includes a hybrid plan, the Georgia State Employees’ Pension and Savings Plan (GSEPS), for state employees hired on or after January 1, 2009. GSEPS combines a smaller DB pension component with a mandatory 401(k) component managed under Peach State Reserves.⁴¹
• Rollover Limitations (Annuity): Consistent with the nature of DB plans, the promised lifetime annuity benefit from ERSGA and TRSGA is not a lump-sum account balance that can be rolled over into an IRA while actively employed or generally upon retirement.⁴¹ The plans are designed to provide income streams, not portable balances.
• Refund of Contributions (Upon Separation): Members who terminate employment covered by ERSGA or TRSGA before meeting retirement eligibility requirements can typically elect to receive a refund of their accumulated employee contributions plus accrued interest.⁴⁷ Accepting this refund results in the forfeiture of all rights to any future pension benefit from the system based on that service period.⁴⁷
• Rollover of Refund: The lump-sum refund of contributions and interest is generally eligible for rollover into a Traditional IRA (including SDIRA), potentially a Roth IRA (for after-tax portions), or another qualified employer plan.⁴⁷ If the refund is paid directly to the member, the taxable portion (interest earned, and potentially some employer contributions for ERS “Old Plan” members) is subject to mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding.⁴⁷ Employee contributions made on an after-tax basis (common in these plans) are not taxed upon refund but can be rolled over.⁴⁷ A direct rollover to an IRA custodian avoids the withholding.⁵¹
• Partial Lump-Sum Option Plan (PLOP): Both ERSGA and TRSGA offer a PLOP feature available only at the time of normal service retirement (meeting specific age and service requirements, typically age 60 with 10 years of service or 30 years of service at any age; early or disability retirements are generally ineligible).⁴³ The PLOP allows a retiree to elect an immediate lump-sum payment, calculated as a multiple (e.g., between 1 and 36 times) of their maximum monthly annuity amount, in exchange for a permanently reduced lifetime monthly pension payment.⁴³ The reduction is actuarially calculated based on the retiree’s age, the PLOP amount chosen, and the specific retirement payment option selected (e.g., single life, survivor option).⁵² The combined value of the lump sum and the reduced annuity is designed to be actuarially equivalent to the original, unreduced annuity.⁵²
• Rollover of PLOP: The lump-sum amount received through the PLOP is an eligible rollover distribution.⁵⁰ It can be rolled over directly to a Traditional IRA (including SDIRA) or another qualified plan to defer income taxes.⁵² If the PLOP distribution is paid directly to the retiree, the taxable portion is subject to 20% mandatory federal withholding.⁵⁰ An additional 10% early distribution tax might apply if the retiree is under age 55 (for ERSGA PLOP) or potentially under 59.5, depending on specific circumstances, though retirement itself often provides exceptions.⁵¹
• In-Service Access: There is generally no provision for active employees to access or roll over funds from the ERSGA or TRSGA defined benefit pension plans. The PLOP is strictly a retirement feature.
• GSEPS Hybrid Plan (ERSGA): For employees under GSEPS, the situation is mixed. The DB pension component follows the standard DB rules (no active rollover, potential refund on separation, PLOP at retirement). The mandatory 401(k) component, however, follows DC plan rules, discussed under Peach State Reserves below.⁴¹ GSEPS members contribute 1.25% to the DB plan and are automatically enrolled at 5% (with up to 3% employer match) in the 401(k), though the default contribution was initially 1% employee/1% employer match.⁴¹

B. Judicial Retirement System (JRS) & Georgia State Pension Fund (GSPERS) Pensions

• Plan Type: The Georgia Judicial Retirement System (JRS) covers judges, district attorneys, and certain other legal personnel, operating as a defined benefit plan.⁵⁵ Members generally contribute 7.5% of compensation (plus 0.25% for Group Term Life Insurance).⁵⁵ Vesting typically requires 10 years of creditable service, and normal retirement is available at age 60 with 10 or more years of service.⁵⁵ GSPERS, likely covering legislators and potentially other officials, is assumed to operate under a similar DB structure, although specific details on its rollover rules were not present in the provided materials. Its limitations likely mirror those of ERSGA and TRSGA.
• Rollover Limitations: JRS, like other state DB plans, provides a lifetime annuity benefit that is not rollable.⁵⁵ Upon separation before vesting (10 years), a refund of employee contributions is available.⁵⁵ It is probable, though not explicitly stated for JRS in the snippets, that this refund would be rollable, similar to ERSGA/TRSGA refunds, with forfeiture of the pension right. JRS does allow incoming transfers from ERS within 90 days of joining JRS for members moving between systems, but this facilitates service consolidation, not rollovers out to an SDIRA.⁵⁵ Whether JRS offers a PLOP-like feature at retirement requires confirmation from specific JRS plan documents.
• In-Service Access: Accessing the core JRS (or assumed GSPERS) DB funds for rollover while actively employed is presumed unavailable.

C. Peach State Reserves (PSR) – 401(k) & 457(b) Plans

Peach State Reserves (PSR) offers supplemental defined contribution (DC) retirement savings plans – a 401(k) and a 457(b) – available to many state employees, often alongside their primary DB pension.⁴¹ Employees can frequently participate in both PSR plans concurrently.⁶⁰

• Rollover Eligibility (Separated/Retired): Upon separation from state employment (usually following a 30-day waiting period), participants can roll over their vested account balances from both the PSR 401(k) and 457(b) plans.⁴⁵ Eligible destinations include Traditional IRAs (including SDIRAs), Roth IRAs (subject to tax rules for pre-tax rollovers), or other qualified employer plans (e.g., a new employer’s 401(k) or 403(b)).⁴⁹ Direct rollovers are advisable to avoid withholding.
• Rollovers Into PSR: The PSR 401(k) plan generally accepts incoming rollovers from previous employer 401(k), 403(b), and governmental 457 plans, and sometimes from IRAs.⁴⁵ The PSR 457(b) plan, however, typically only accepts incoming rollovers from other governmental 457(b) plans.⁴⁵ An employee wishing to consolidate funds from a non-457 source into PSR while contributing to the 457 plan would need to roll the external funds into the PSR 401(k).⁴⁵
• In-Service Withdrawals/Rollovers (Active Employees): Access while actively employed differs between the two plans:

• PSR 401(k): Generally, withdrawals and rollovers are restricted prior to separation from service or reaching age 59.5.⁶¹ In-service withdrawals are permitted for participants aged 59.5 or older (though employer contributions might remain restricted until separation).⁶¹ These age 59.5 withdrawals can likely be directly rolled over to an IRA/SDIRA. Financial hardship withdrawals are available under very strict IRS criteria and typically only apply to employee contributions (excluding earnings and employer money); these are unlikely to be eligible for rollover.⁵⁹ Withdrawals taken before age 59.5 that are not rolled over are generally subject to a 10% federal penalty tax in addition to regular income tax.⁵⁹
• PSR 457(b): Historically, 457(b) plans had stricter in-service withdrawal rules. However, following federal legislative changes (SECURE Act), PSR allows in-service withdrawals for participants aged 59.5 or older (changed from age 70.5 effective Jan 1, 2022).⁶¹ These could potentially be rolled over. Withdrawals due to an “unforeseeable emergency” (a stricter standard than 401(k) hardship) are permitted but likely not rollable.⁵⁹ A “de minimis” withdrawal option exists for accounts under $5,000 that have been inactive for two years.⁶¹ The most significant feature of governmental 457(b) plans like PSR’s is the absence of the 10% early withdrawal penalty for distributions taken after separation from service, regardless of the participant’s age.⁵⁹ This makes the 457(b) attractive for early retirees. However, this advantage is lost if the 457(b) funds are rolled over into an IRA, 401(k), or 403(b). Once in the new plan type, those funds become subject to the standard 10% penalty if withdrawn before age 59.5.⁴⁹
• Vesting: While employee contributions to PSR plans are always 100% vested, employer matching contributions, such as those in the GSEPS 401(k) component, are subject to a vesting schedule. For PSR, this is typically a 5-year graded schedule (20% vested per year of service).⁴⁵ Only the vested portion of the account balance is eligible for rollover or distribution.⁴⁵

The structure of Georgia’s state retirement systems largely mirrors the federal landscape concerning DB plan limitations. For ERSGA, TRSGA, and JRS members, the primary pension benefit is an annuity, inaccessible for rollover while active.⁴¹ Access before retirement generally requires separating and taking a contribution refund, which means forfeiting the pension.⁴⁷ This presents the same fundamental barrier for active employees as seen with FERS/CSRS.

The PLOP feature in ERSGA and TRSGA ⁵² does create a rollable lump sum, but only at the point of retirement and at the cost of a permanently reduced lifetime annuity. It is a liquidity event tied to retirement commencement, not a tool for active employees seeking diversification. It represents a significant trade-off – immediate cash (rollable) versus lower lifelong income.

The Peach State Reserves 457(b) plan ⁴⁵ offers a notable advantage with its exemption from the 10% early withdrawal penalty upon separation from service, regardless of age.⁶⁶ This could be appealing for early retirees. However, a potential pitfall exists: rolling these penalty-free accessible funds into an SDIRA (which is an IRA) subjects them to the standard IRA rules. If the individual then needs to withdraw funds from the SDIRA before age 59.5, the 10% penalty, initially avoided, would apply.⁴⁹ For an early retiree needing potential access to funds before 59.5, taking distributions directly from the PSR 457(b) might offer more flexibility than rolling them into an SDIRA.

V. Supplemental Plan Rollover Rules (General 403(b), 401(k), 457(b))

Federal and Georgia state employees may also participate in supplemental retirement plans outside their primary systems. These could include plans from previous employers, spousal plans, or additional plans offered by their current employer (though less common for primary state/federal roles beyond TSP/PSR). Understanding the general rollover rules for these common plan types (403(b), 457(b), 401(k)) is relevant.

A. General Principles

These defined contribution (DC) plans hold assets in individual accounts. Rollover eligibility primarily depends on the plan’s specific rules and the participant’s employment status and age. The IRS sets the overarching framework, but individual plan documents dictate the available options.⁷⁰

B. 403(b) Plans

Commonly found in public education (K-12, universities) and non-profit organizations (501(c)(3)), some state or federal employees might have funds in a 403(b) from prior employment.

• Rollover Eligibility: Typically, 403(b) funds become eligible for rollover when the participant separates from the service of the employer sponsoring the plan.⁷² In-service rollovers while still actively employed are generally not permitted before age 59.5, although plan documents should be checked.⁷² Once eligible, funds can usually be rolled over to a Traditional IRA (including SDIRA), Roth IRA (as a taxable conversion if pre-tax funds are involved), another 403(b) plan, a 401(k) plan, or a governmental 457(b) plan that accepts such rollovers.⁷²
• Process: Direct rollovers (plan-to-plan or plan-to-IRA custodian) are strongly recommended.⁷² This avoids the mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding that applies to the taxable portion of eligible rollover distributions paid directly to the participant.²⁵ If an indirect rollover is done (participant receives a check), the funds must be deposited into the new eligible retirement account within 60 days of receipt.²⁵ To roll over the full amount, the participant must use personal funds to replace the 20% that was withheld.²⁵
• Roth Conversions: Moving pre-tax 403(b) assets to a Roth IRA is permissible but triggers income tax liability on the rolled-over amount in the year of the conversion.⁷³
• After-Tax Contributions: If a 403(b) plan holds both pre-tax and after-tax contributions, IRS Notice 2014-54 allows for splitting the rollover.³⁷ For example, the pre-tax amounts can be directly rolled to a Traditional IRA, while the after-tax amounts can be directly rolled to a Roth IRA, without forcing a pro-rata distribution of both types to each destination.³⁷

C. 457(b) Plans (Governmental)

These plans are available to state and local government employees (like the Peach State Reserves 457b).

• Rollover Eligibility: Funds in a governmental 457(b) plan can typically be rolled over after separation from service.⁶⁷ Some plans might permit in-service distributions or rollovers after the participant reaches age 59.5.⁶⁷ Eligible destinations include Traditional IRAs (including SDIRAs), Roth IRAs (taxable conversion), 401(k) plans, 403(b) plans, and other governmental 457(b) plans.⁶⁷
• Key Feature & Rollover Consequence: As highlighted previously, the major advantage of governmental 457(b) plans is the exemption from the 10% early withdrawal penalty for distributions taken after separation from service, regardless of age.⁶⁷ However, if these funds are rolled into any other type of plan (IRA, 401(k), 403(b)), they lose this special protection and become subject to the standard 10% penalty if withdrawn from the new plan before age 59.5.⁶⁷
• Non-Governmental 457(b) Plans: These plans, offered by some tax-exempt non-profit organizations, have significantly more restrictive rollover rules. Generally, funds from a non-governmental 457(b) can only be rolled over to another non-governmental 457(b) plan.⁶⁷ They cannot be rolled into IRAs, 401(k)s, or 403(b)s.⁶⁷ These plans are also technically assets of the employer until paid out, not held in trust for the employee.⁶⁸

D. 401(k) Plans (General)

While federal employees have the TSP and Georgia state employees may have the PSR 401(k), they might also have funds in standard 401(k) plans from previous private sector employment.

• Rollover Eligibility: Similar to 403(b) plans, 401(k) funds are typically eligible for rollover upon separation from the sponsoring employer’s service.²⁵ Some plans may allow in-service distributions or rollovers once the participant reaches age 59.5. Eligible destinations include Traditional IRAs (including SDIRAs), Roth IRAs (taxable conversion), other 401(k) plans, 403(b) plans, and governmental 457(b) plans.
• Process: Direct rollovers are preferred to avoid the 20% mandatory withholding on the taxable portion of distributions paid to the participant.²⁵ Indirect rollovers must be completed within 60 days.²⁵

Across these common supplemental DC plans, a clear pattern emerges: separation from the employer sponsoring the plan is the most universally recognized event triggering rollover eligibility.⁶⁷ While some plans may permit in-service access after age 59.5 ⁶⁷, this is not guaranteed and depends on the specific plan’s provisions. This reinforces the significant challenge for active employees, particularly those under 59.5, who wish to access funds from these types of accounts for an SDIRA rollover. Their employment status is the primary gatekeeper.

Furthermore, while IRS regulations provide the general rules and possibilities for rollovers, the specific features and permissions offered by any individual 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b) plan are ultimately determined by the plan’s written document.⁷⁰ An employee cannot assume, for instance, that their plan allows for age 59.5 in-service rollovers or accepts incoming rollovers just because the IRS permits such features in general. Verification with the specific plan administrator or review of the Summary Plan Description (SPD) is essential.

VI. Synthesized Feasibility Assessment

Synthesizing the rollover rules for federal and Georgia state primary and supplemental retirement plans allows for a clearer assessment of the feasibility of using these funds to establish an SDIRA for SFR investments.

A. Comparing Rollover Ease: Defined Contribution (DC) vs. Defined Benefit (DB) Plans

• DC Plans (TSP, PSR 401k/457b, Supplemental 401k/403b): These plans are fundamentally based on individual account balances. The process of rolling over these balances is relatively straightforward once a triggering event occurs (typically separation from service or attainment of age 59.5). The main barrier is meeting the conditions for eligibility to move the funds out of the plan. The assets exist as a quantifiable sum directly attributable to the participant.
• DB Plans (FERS, CSRS, ERSGA, TRSGA, JRS, GSPERS): These plans promise a future income stream (annuity), not an accessible account balance. Rolling over the core pension benefit while actively employed is generally impossible. The primary methods to access funds involve events that fundamentally alter or forfeit the pension:

1. Contribution Refund: Available upon separation before retirement eligibility, but requires giving up the lifetime annuity.³⁰ The refund amount is typically limited to employee contributions plus interest, not the full actuarial value of the promised pension.
2. PLOP (ERSGA/TRSGA): Available only at retirement, providing a partial lump sum (which is rollable) in exchange for a permanently reduced annuity.⁵² This is not an in-service option.
3. CSRS VCP: A unique exception allowing rollover of voluntary after-tax contributions and interest, separate from the main pension.³⁸ Accessing DB funds for rollover is thus structurally far more difficult and often involves significant trade-offs compared to DC plans.

B. Impact of Employment Status: Active vs. Separated/Retired Employees

• Active Employees (Under Age 59.5): Feasibility is extremely low for using primary retirement funds. They cannot access DB pension benefits for rollover [Insight 4, Insight 7]. Access to TSP, PSR plans, and other supplemental DC plans is generally blocked until separation or age 59.5, unless a specific plan document allows for unusual in-service rollovers (rare) [Insight 10]. Hardship withdrawals are not rollable.²⁵ The only notable exception is the CSRS VCP for eligible CSRS employees.⁴⁰ For most active employees in this age group, funding an SDIRA via rollover from their main retirement plans is practically infeasible.
• Active Employees (Age 59.5 and Older): Feasibility improves significantly for accessing DC plan assets. They can potentially make in-service withdrawals/rollovers from the TSP ²⁸, PSR 401(k) and 457(b) plans ⁶¹, and potentially other supplemental 401(k)/403(b) plans, if permitted by the specific plan documents [Insight 11]. They still cannot access their primary DB pension funds while actively employed.
• Separated/Retired Employees: This group has the highest feasibility for executing rollovers. They can:

• Roll over vested balances from TSP, PSR plans, and other supplemental DC plans.²²
• Choose to take a contribution refund from their DB plan (if separating before retirement) and roll that refund into an IRA, although this means forfeiting the pension.³⁰
• Utilize the PLOP option from ERSGA/TRSGA at the point of retirement to generate a rollable lump sum, accepting a lower lifetime annuity.⁵² While separated/retired employees have the most options, accessing DB plan funds still typically involves sacrificing or reducing the guaranteed pension benefit.

C. Rollover Feasibility Summary Table

The following table summarizes the likelihood and conditions under which federal and Georgia state employees can roll funds into an SDIRA from various retirement plans.

Table 1: Feasibility of Rolling Retirement Funds to an SDIRA for Federal & Georgia State Employees

(Note: “Feasible” indicates the plan rules generally allow rollover under the specified condition, but individual plan documents and administrative procedures must always be confirmed. “Limited” indicates access requires forfeiting or reducing the primary pension benefit.)

The feasibility analysis reveals a significant divide. Funding an SDIRA with retirement assets is largely achievable for employees who have separated or retired, particularly using DC plan balances (TSP, PSR, supplemental plans) or, with major caveats, DB plan contribution refunds. However, for the group potentially most motivated by current market concerns – active employees under age 59.5 – the path is generally blocked for accessing their primary retirement funds (both DB and DC) for this purpose [Insight 12]. The age 59.5 threshold represents a critical inflection point, opening up possibilities for accessing DC plan funds while still employed, though DB pensions remain largely inaccessible.

This creates a potential mismatch: the employees most likely seeking immediate diversification away from market volatility (active employees in their accumulation phase) are precisely those with the least ability to use their main retirement accounts to fund an SDIRA [Insight 13]. Conversely, those who can more readily access funds (separated/retired individuals or active employees over 59.5) may have different financial priorities, such as income preservation, liquidity needs, or lower risk tolerance, which might make illiquid, complex SDIRA strategies less appealing compared to their existing pension or more traditional investments.

VII. Evaluating SFR Strategies in an SDIRA Context

Assuming an employee can successfully navigate the rollover hurdles and fund an SDIRA, the next step is evaluating whether the proposed SFR strategies—direct rentals, private debt funds, first trust deeds—effectively address the goals of mitigating stock market volatility and generating income, while considering their inherent risks compared to a traditional portfolio.

A. Addressing User Goals: Mitigating Volatility and Generating Income

• Volatility Mitigation: Real estate investments are often sought for diversification because their performance is not perfectly correlated with the stock market.⁷ Holding tangible assets like property or debt secured by property can feel more stable than owning shares subject to daily market swings.⁷ However, this does not equate to an absence of risk or volatility. Real estate markets have their own cycles, influenced by interest rates, economic conditions, and local factors.⁸ A downturn in the property market can lead to value declines. Furthermore, the primary risk mitigation tool in traditional investing – diversification – can be undermined by direct SFR ownership, which often concentrates a significant portion of capital into a single asset or geographic location.⁴ Perhaps the most critical difference regarding volatility is liquidity. Stocks can be sold quickly, allowing investors to react to market changes (though potentially locking in losses). Real estate is inherently illiquid; selling can take months or longer, especially in unfavorable market conditions, making it difficult to exit a position quickly if needed.⁴
• Income Generation: SFR strategies can align well with the goal of generating income. Rental properties can produce regular cash flow from tenants.⁷ Private lending through notes or trust deeds provides fixed interest payments to the SDIRA.³ Investing in private debt funds can also yield periodic income distributions.¹² However, the consistency and amount of this income are not guaranteed. Rental income depends on occupancy rates, timely rent payments, and managing operating expenses (taxes, insurance, repairs, management fees).⁹ Loan income depends on the borrower’s ability and willingness to pay; defaults interrupt cash flow and necessitate potentially costly collection or foreclosure actions.¹³

B. In-Depth Strategy Review: Benefits vs. Risks

Each SFR strategy within an SDIRA presents a distinct profile of potential rewards and challenges:

• Direct Rental Ownership:

• Benefits: Potential for both rental income and long-term capital appreciation; real estate can serve as an inflation hedge; direct control over the specific asset chosen.⁷
• Risks: High illiquidity ⁸; significant hands-on management burden, even when hiring property managers (due diligence, oversight required); vacancy risk leading to income loss; unexpected maintenance and repair costs; localized market risk (value decline in specific area); high concentration risk ⁴; substantial capital required for purchase or reliance on non-recourse loans which trigger potential UDFI tax ¹⁶; extreme vulnerability to prohibited transaction rule violations (e.g., no personal use by owner or family, no performing personal labor on the property, meticulous separation of IRA and personal finances).⁶ The compliance burden is arguably highest with this strategy.
• Private Debt Funds (SFR Focused):

• Benefits: Access to a diversified portfolio of loans potentially across different properties, borrowers, and locations, managed by professionals; generally passive involvement for the SDIRA owner; avoids direct property management hassles ¹⁰; potential for regular income distributions.
• Risks: Significant counterparty risk – reliance on the fund manager’s expertise, diligence, and ethical conduct ¹²; potentially high fees (management, performance, administrative) that reduce net returns; illiquidity due to fund lock-up periods (often several years) ¹²; lack of transparency compared to public investments ⁴; complexity in performing due diligence on the fund, its strategy, and its manager ¹²; potential for UBIT/UDFI if the fund employs leverage ¹²; often restricted to accredited investors (requiring specific income or net worth thresholds).¹²
• First Trust Deeds / Direct Note Investing:

• Benefits: Investment is secured by tangible real estate collateral, offering a degree of principal protection if structured properly (e.g., with sufficient equity/low Loan-to-Value ratio) ³; potential for attractive fixed-income returns, often higher than traditional bonds or CDs ¹⁰; generates passive income through regular interest payments ⁸; loan durations can be shorter than holding equity real estate ⁷⁶; non-judicial foreclosure process in many jurisdictions can be faster than mortgage foreclosures if default occurs.¹³
• Risks: Borrower default is the primary risk, requiring the lender (SDIRA) to potentially initiate foreclosure ¹³; foreclosure process, even if non-judicial, involves costs, time, and potentially managing/selling the foreclosed property ¹³; interest rate risk – if market rates rise significantly, the value of an existing fixed-rate note may decline; high illiquidity – notes are difficult to sell before maturity ¹³; requires extensive due diligence on the borrower’s creditworthiness, the property’s value and condition (to ensure adequate LTV cushion), and the specific terms of the note and deed of trust ¹³; concentration risk if investing in only one or a few notes.¹⁴

C. Comparative Analysis: SDIRA/SFR vs. Traditional Diversified Portfolio

Comparing these SDIRA strategies against maintaining a traditional, diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, and mutual funds reveals critical trade-offs:

• Liquidity: Traditional portfolios offer high liquidity, allowing assets to be bought or sold quickly on public exchanges during market hours. SDIRA/SFR investments are fundamentally illiquid, potentially tying up capital for years.⁴ This lack of access can be a major disadvantage if funds are needed for emergencies or RMDs.
• Diversification: Traditional portfolios allow for easy, broad diversification across thousands of securities, multiple asset classes, industries, and geographies, significantly reducing concentration risk. Direct SFR ownership inherently concentrates risk.⁴ While debt funds offer some diversification, it’s typically within the single sector of real estate debt. Achieving meaningful diversification through direct note investing requires holding numerous notes.¹⁴
• Complexity & Management: Investing in traditional assets can be done passively through low-cost index funds or actively with professional advisors. SDIRA/SFR investing demands significant active involvement from the investor, including sourcing deals, performing extensive due diligence, ensuring strict IRS compliance, managing custodians, and potentially overseeing property managers or navigating foreclosures.⁴
• Fees & Costs: While traditional investing involves brokerage commissions or fund expense ratios (which can be very low for index funds, like those in TSP ²³), SDIRA/SFR investing involves multiple layers of costs: SDIRA custodian fees (often higher than standard IRAs) ⁴, real estate transaction costs (closing costs, agent fees), ongoing property expenses (taxes, insurance, maintenance), potential UBIT/UDFI taxes ¹⁶, and potentially high fees within private debt funds.¹²
• Regulation & Transparency: Publicly traded securities and the markets they trade on are subject to extensive regulation and disclosure requirements (e.g., by the SEC). Alternative investments common in SDIRAs often operate with significantly less regulatory oversight and transparency, increasing the risk of fraud and making due diligence more challenging.⁴
• “Safety” Perception: A traditional diversified portfolio seeks safety through broad diversification, liquidity, and regulatory oversight, aiming to mitigate company-specific risk and provide access to capital. SDIRA/SFR strategies seek safety through tangible assets or collateral but introduce substantial counterbalancing risks: illiquidity, concentration, operational complexity, compliance pitfalls, and counterparty risk [Insight 14]. The perception of SFR investing as inherently “safer” than a diversified stock/bond portfolio warrants careful examination, as it primarily represents a trade-off between different types of risk.

The decision to pursue SFR investments within an SDIRA involves a fundamental shift in the nature of risks undertaken. The volatility associated with public markets is exchanged for the risks of illiquidity, operational complexity, stringent compliance requirements, concentration, and the need for specialized due diligence [Insight 14]. This is not an elimination of risk, but a transformation. Investors must honestly assess which set of risks they are better equipped and more comfortable managing.

Compounding this is the amplified burden of due diligence. Given the reduced regulatory oversight and transparency in many alternative investment markets ⁴, and the explicitly administrative, non-advisory role of the SDIRA custodian ⁴, the investor is solely responsible for thoroughly vetting every aspect of the deal – the property, the borrower, the fund manager, the legal structure, and compliance with SDIRA rules [Insight 15]. This requires a level of expertise and effort far exceeding that needed for selecting publicly traded stocks or mutual funds, often necessitating the hiring of costly independent professionals.⁴

Finally, the prohibited transaction rules represent a significant hazard, particularly for direct real estate ownership [Insight 16]. The lines between permissible management and impermissible personal benefit or dealing with disqualified persons can be easily blurred.⁵ Simple errors, such as using a personal credit card for an IRA property expense (even if intending to reimburse immediately) or having a child stay overnight in an IRA-owned rental, can lead to catastrophic consequences, including the disqualification of the entire IRA.¹ This high compliance risk demands meticulous record-keeping and a thorough understanding of the rules.

VIII. Key Considerations and Recommendations

Based on the analysis of retirement plan rules and the nature of SDIRA real estate investing, federal and Georgia state employees considering this strategy should weigh the following critical factors:

• Defined Benefit Plan Limitations: The most significant barrier is the general inability to roll over funds from primary DB pension plans (FERS, CSRS, ERSGA, TRSGA, JRS, GSPERS) while actively employed. Access typically requires separation from service and accepting a refund of contributions, which means forfeiting the guaranteed lifetime pension annuity – a decision with major long-term financial implications. The PLOP option available in some Georgia plans provides a rollable lump sum only at retirement and reduces the ongoing pension.
• Defined Contribution Plan Access Timing: Rollover eligibility for DC plans (TSP, PSR 401k/457b, supplemental 401k/403b) is predominantly tied to separation from service or, for some plans, reaching age 59.5 while still employed. Active employees under age 59.5 generally cannot access these funds for an SDIRA rollover.
• Complexity and Compliance Burden: SDIRAs, especially those holding real estate, operate under complex IRS rules. Prohibited transactions, disqualified person rules, and potential UBIT/UDFI taxes require careful navigation.¹ This is not a “set it and forget it” strategy; it demands ongoing diligence and meticulous record-keeping. The consequences of compliance failures are severe, potentially leading to the loss of the IRA’s tax-advantaged status.¹
• Investor Responsibility for Due Diligence: SDIRA custodians merely administer the account; they do not vet investments for quality, legitimacy, or suitability.⁴ The investor bears the full responsibility for researching and evaluating potential investments, counterparties (like fund managers or borrowers), and ensuring compliance [Insight 15]. Given the lack of transparency in some alternative markets, this requires significant expertise or reliance on trusted (and potentially expensive) advisors.⁴ The potential for fraud exists, demanding vigilance.⁴
• Illiquidity Risk: Real estate and private debt investments are inherently illiquid.⁴ Capital can be tied up for extended periods, making it difficult to access funds quickly in case of personal need or to react to changing market conditions. This contrasts sharply with the liquidity of traditional stock and bond investments and must be a primary consideration, especially as retirement approaches.
• Overall Costs: The total cost of this strategy includes SDIRA custodian fees (which are often higher than standard IRA fees), transaction costs associated with real estate (closing costs, appraisals, legal fees), ongoing property expenses (taxes, insurance, maintenance, management fees), potential UBIT/UDFI taxes, and potentially higher investment management fees for private funds.⁴ These costs can significantly impact net returns compared to low-cost options available within plans like the TSP.²³
• Loss of Plan-Specific Benefits: Rolling funds out of employer-sponsored plans means losing access to any unique features they offer. For TSP participants, this includes the G Fund.²³ For those with governmental 457(b) plans like PSR, rolling funds into an IRA forfeits the valuable exemption from the 10% early withdrawal penalty upon separation from service.⁶⁷
• Seek Qualified, Independent Professional Advice: Given the complexities and potential pitfalls, it is crucial for employees considering this strategy to consult with qualified professionals before making any decisions. This should include:

• A fee-only financial advisor familiar with both public sector retirement plans and the intricacies of SDIRAs and alternative investments.
• A Certified Public Accountant (CPA) knowledgeable about SDIRA taxation, including UBIT/UDFI and prohibited transaction consequences.
• Potentially an attorney specializing in ERISA or SDIRA compliance, particularly if complex structures like IRA LLCs or significant direct real estate transactions are contemplated. Ensure advisors are independent and acting in a fiduciary capacity..⁴

Conclusion and Recommendation:

The feasibility of using retirement plan rollovers to fund an SDIRA for SFR investments is highly constrained for most active federal and Georgia state employees, particularly those under age 59.5, due to the restrictive rules governing their primary defined benefit pension plans and the typical requirements for accessing defined contribution plan funds. While pathways exist, primarily for separated/retired employees or active employees over 59.5 using DC plan assets, they often involve significant trade-offs, such as forfeiting a pension annuity or losing plan-specific benefits.

Furthermore, the strategy itself introduces substantial complexities and risks—navigating intricate IRS compliance rules, managing illiquid assets, bearing the full burden of due diligence in often opaque markets, and potentially facing unexpected taxes (UBIT/UDFI). These operational and compliance risks may counteract the perceived benefit of moving away from stock market volatility. The notion of SFR investing within an SDIRA as a straightforward path to “safety” and income should be approached with skepticism; it is a transformation, not an elimination, of risk.

Therefore, this strategy requires extreme caution. It is likely unsuitable or infeasible for a large segment of the target audience, especially active employees seeking immediate diversification. Employees should first explore all diversification and investment options available within their existing low-cost plans (like TSP or PSR). If considering external real estate investments, using non-retirement assets may be simpler and less risky from a compliance standpoint.

For those few who meet the eligibility criteria for rollover (primarily separated/retired or active 59.5+ with DC funds) and still wish to proceed, a deep understanding of the rules, a high tolerance for complexity and illiquidity, and access to expert, independent advice are prerequisites. The potential benefits must be carefully weighed against the considerable risks and hurdles involved.

Works cited

1. Self-Directed IRA: Rules and Regulations – Investopedia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/081816/selfdirected-ira-rules-and-regulations.asp
2. Self Directed IRA in 2025: Benefits, Fees & FAQs | The Entrust Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.theentrustgroup.com/self-directed-iras
3. Self-Directed IRA Investment Options – Real Estate and More – IRAR Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.iraresources.com/self-directed-ira-investments
4. Seven Reasons to Avoid a Self-Directed IRA – Kiplinger, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/retirement-plans/self-directed-ira/604134/6-reasons-to-avoid-a-self-directed-iras
5. Self-Directed IRA Rules, Requirements, Prohibited Transactions – IRAR Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.iraresources.com/self-directed-ira/rules
6. Everything to Know About SDIRA Prohibited Transactions – American Estate and Trust, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.aetrust.com/blog/everything-to-know-about-sdira-prohibited-transactions
7. Self-Directed IRA Investing in Real Estate, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.advantaira.com/real-estate-ira/
8. What is a Self-Directed IRA for Real Estate | Forge Trust, accessed April 12, 2025, https://forgetrust.com/resources/articles/what-is-a-self-directed-ira-for-real-estate/
9. Self Directed IRA for Real Estate: Benefits, Risks, & Next Steps – The Entrust Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.theentrustgroup.com/blog/basics-of-self-directed-iras-and-purchasing-rental-property-with-retirement-funds
10. Private Money Lending With Self-Directed IRAs | IRAR Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.iraresources.com/self-directed-ira-investments/private-lending
11. Private Debt – Self Directed IRA Custodian – STRATA Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.stratatrust.com/self-directed-iras/investment-options/private-debt/
12. Investing in Private Funds & PPMs | Self-Directed IRAs, accessed April 12, 2025, https://directedira.com/private-funds/
13. What Is Trust Deed Investing In an SDIRA? Is it Safe – by Horizon Trust, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.horizontrust.com/what-is-trust-deed-investing-is-it-safe/
14. First Deed of Trust Investing Risks – Saint Investment, accessed April 12, 2025, https://saintinvestment.com/blog/first-deed-of-trust-investing-risks/
15. Self-Directed IRA Real Estate Investing – Equity Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trustetc.com/investments/real-estate/
16. UBIT Tax – UDFI – UBTI : The Ultimate Guide to IRA Taxes – IRAR Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.iraresources.com/self-directed-ira/ubit-unrelated-business-income-tax
17. Real Estate Syndications & UBIT/UDFI Tax | Directed IRA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://directedira.com/self-directed-iras-real-estate-syndications-and-ubit-udfi-tax/
18. Understanding UDFI & UBIT in a Self-Directed IRA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.advantaira.com/self-directed-ira/ubit-udfi/
19. What is a Prohibited Transaction in an SDIRA? – STRATA Trust Company, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.stratatrust.com/insights/what-is-a-prohibited-transaction-in-an-sdira/
20. How to Avoid Self-Directed IRA Prohibited Transactions – The Entrust Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.theentrustgroup.com/blog/self-directed-ira-prohibited-transactions
21. Pros & Cons of Self-Directed IRAs in Real Estate Investing – First National Realty Partners, accessed April 12, 2025, https://fnrpusa.com/blog/pros-cons-self-directed-ira-real-estate/
22. How to Rollover a TSP to a Self-Directed IRA: Step-by-Step – by Horizon Trust, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.horizontrust.com/how-to-rollover-a-tsp-to-a-self-directed-ira-step-by-step/
23. Pros and Cons of a TSP Rollover: What You Need to Know – Capitalize, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.hicapitalize.com/resources/pros-and-cons-of-tsp-rollover/
24. Move Money Into the TSP, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tsp.gov/tsp-basics/move-money-into-tsp/
25. Topic no. 413, Rollovers from retirement plans | Internal Revenue Service, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc413
26. Withdrawals In-Service – Thrift Savings Plan, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tsp.gov/publications/tspbk12.pdf
27. Understanding the Thrift Savings Plan Withdrawal Process – MOAA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.moaa.org/content/publications-and-media/news-articles/2024-news-articles/finance/understanding-the-thrift-savings-plan-withdrawal-process/
28. In-service Withdrawal Types and Terms | The Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tsp.gov/in-service-withdrawal-basics/in-service-withdrawal-types-and-terms/
29. Pensions and annuity withholding | Internal Revenue Service, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/pensions-and-annuity-withholding
30. Former Employees – OPM, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.opm.gov/retirement-center/fers-information/former-employees/
31. Can I roll over my refund of retirement contributions? – OPM.gov, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.opm.gov/frequently-asked-questions/retire-faq/leaving-the-government/can-i-roll-over-my-refund-of-retirement-contributions/
32. FERS Payments for Federal Employees, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.federaldisability.com/former-government-employee-may-apply/
33. FERS Contributions – Plan Your Federal Retirement, accessed April 12, 2025, https://plan-your-federal-retirement.com/fers-contributions/
34. What Will Happen to My Annuity if I Leave Federal Service? | Harris, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.federaldisability.com/annuity-leave-federal-service/
35. How Federal Employees Can Secure Retirement Contribution Refunds – MOAA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.moaa.org/content/publications-and-media/news-articles/2024-news-articles/finance/how-federal-employees-can-secure-retirement-contribution-refunds/
36. Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions | Internal Revenue Service, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/rollovers-of-retirement-plan-and-ira-distributions
37. Rollovers of after-tax contributions in retirement plans | Internal Revenue Service, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/rollovers-of-after-tax-contributions-in-retirement-plans
38. CSRS Retirement – CovingtonAlsina, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.covingtonalsina.com/p/csrs-retirement
39. CSRS VCP Transfer to Roth IRA – Plan Your Federal Retirement, accessed April 12, 2025, https://plan-your-federal-retirement.com/csrs-vcp-to-roth-ira/
40. VCP: The CSRS Voluntary Contribution Program – Part II – Serving Those Who Serve, accessed April 12, 2025, https://stwserve.com/vcp-the-csrs-voluntary-contribution-program-part-ii/
41. SNAPSHOT: Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia Key Facts, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.nirsonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/georgia.pdf
42. ERSGA Glossary – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/ersga-glossary
43. Retirement Plans Offered | Teachers Retirement System of Georgia – TRSGA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trsga.com/about-us/trs-plans/
44. ROLLOVER – Teachers Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trsga.com/library/files/forms/DirectRolloverRequest.pdf
45. 401(k) AND 457 PLANS HANDBOOK – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/psr_handbook.pdf
46. GSEPS PLAN HIGHLIGHTS, accessed April 12, 2025, https://gwinnetttech.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/gseps_plan_highlights.pdf
47. GDCP Handbook – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/post/gdcp-handbook
48. Plan Guide – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/gdcp_handbook.pdf
49. ersga, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/separating_employees_faq.pdf?1512762423
50. Start Thinking – Teachers Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trsga.com/library/files/publications/Pre-Retirement-Handout.pdf
51. Special Tax Notice Safe Harbor Explanations – Eligible Rollover Distributions – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/post/special-tax-notice
52. Partial Lump-Sum Option Payment, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/plop.pdf?1678898143
53. Partial Lump Sum Option Plan (PLOP) | Teachers Retirement System of Georgia – TRSGA, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trsga.com/about-us/trs-plans/partial-lump-sum-option-plan/
54. Partial Lump-Sum Option Plan – Teachers Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.trsga.com/library/files/general/Partial-Lump-Sum-Option_Web.pdf
55. Georgia Judicial Retirement System (JRS) Benefits at a Glance, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/benefitsataglancegjrs.pdf?1721835602
56. Unofficial Opinion 2000-8 – Georgia Attorney General’s Office, accessed April 12, 2025, https://law.georgia.gov/opinions/2000-8
57. H.B. 905 – LegiScan, accessed April 12, 2025, https://legiscan.com/GA/supplement/HB905/id/566122/Georgia-2025-HB905-Auditor_s_Certification.pdf
58. State Auditor H.B. 900 – LegiScan, accessed April 12, 2025, https://legiscan.com/GA/supplement/HB900/id/566120/Georgia-2025-HB900-Auditor_s_Certification.pdf
59. Peach State Reserves FAQ, accessed April 12, 2025, https://gefa.georgia.gov/document/publication/peach-state-reserves-faqpdf/download
60. Peach State Reserves (PSR) – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/peach-state-reserves
61. 401(k) AND 457 PLAN COMPARISON – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/plancompare.pdf?1724691584
62. Peach State Reserves (PSR) Handbook – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/psr-handbook
63. Benefits of Peach State Reserves – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/psr_updated_webinar_2017.pdf
64. PEACH STATE RESERVES Program Summary – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/sites/main/files/file-attachments/psr_plan_summary_.pdf?1568401736
65. Changes to Peach State Reserves – Employees’ Retirement System of Georgia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.ers.ga.gov/post/changes-peach-state-reserves
66. At What Age Can I Withdraw From My 457(b) Without Penalty?, accessed April 12, 2025, https://georgiasaferetirementplanners.com/at-what-age-can-i-withdraw-from-my-457b-without-penalty/
67. How a 457 Plan Works After Retirement: Withdrawals and Rollovers – Investopedia, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/020116/how-457-plan-works-after-retirement.asp
68. What is a 457(b) plan and how does it work? – Fidelity Investments, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/smart-money/what-is-a-457b
69. Fact Sheet – 457 Rollovers and Transfers, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.nrsforu.com/nrs/media/images/nrsCommon/factsheet457rollovers.pdf
70. IRC 403(b) tax-sheltered annuity plans | Internal Revenue Service, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/irc-403b-tax-sheltered-annuity-plans
71. IRC Section 457(b) Eligible Deferred Compensation Plan – Written Plan Requirements – IRS, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/irc-section-457b-eligible-deferred-compensation-plan-written-plan-requirements
72. How to Roll Over a 403(b) to an IRA – Retirement – SmartAsset, accessed April 12, 2025, https://smartasset.com/retirement/how-to-roll-over-a-403b-to-an-ira
73. 403(b) Rollover Options – MissionSquare Retirement, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.missionsq.org/products-and-services/403(b)-defined-contribution-plans/403(b)-rollover-options.html
74. 457(b) Retirement Plan Rollover Options | MissionSquare, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.missionsq.org/products-and-services/457(b)-deferred-compensation-plans/457(b)-retirement-plan-rollover-options.html
75. Sec. 457 government plan distributions compared to 401(k) distributions – The Tax Adviser, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.thetaxadviser.com/issues/2021/feb/sec-457-government-plan-401k-distributions/
76. Trust Deeds: The Unsung Hero of Alternative Real Estate Investments – REI INK, accessed April 12, 2025, https://rei-ink.com/trust-deeds-the-unsung-hero-of-alternative-real-estate-investments/